Career “pathways” have become a big idea in high school reform. The objective is to provide all trainees a structured series of courses in a profession field, along with early direct exposure to the workplace and chances to build useful, occupational skills.
Many aspects of these programs resemble the curriculums at traditional trade schools. However this newer version simultaneously aims to make the occupation high school more college oriented and the comprehensive high school more career oriented.
Are the countless dollars bought these programs actually helping students get a running start on college and professions?
That question can’t be fully answered yet. But a new research report from Delaware– a national leader in the pathways movement– provides some early clues.
The state launched profession paths in 2014. Today, about 70 percent of high school trainees, or 30,000 teens, are registered, according to the nonprofit Rodel, which deals with Delaware policymakers to reform education and enhance the state’s workforce.
Preferably, trainees take a sequence of three or more courses in fields like healthcare, construction or education. Lots of likewise earn early college credits or make significant progress towards market certifications, and some take part in internships or apprenticeships.
Scientists at RTI International, a nonprofit research study company, tracked more than 6,000 graduates who had finished a minimum of 2 courses in a profession field and surveyed them to see what they were carrying out in the years instantly after high school.
Three-quarters of the trainees surveyed were registered in college or another postsecondary training program after graduation, which is higher than the national average of 63 percent. But less than half were still studying or operating in the field they had picked in high school.
For instance, amongst trainees who finished a pathway in architecture and construction, less than 20 percent pursued construction-related majors. Numerous moved instead to fields like science and engineering (40 percent), service (8 percent) or health care (6 percent).
Most popular high-school pathway fields in Delaware
* Other paths are a selection of career fields, each totaling less than 5 percent of path graduates. Source: Delaware Pathways Outcomes Research Study– Final Report, April 2026, RTI International
That mismatch isn’t always a failure. For some trainees, the wrong course was clarifying.
“When the students talked to us about it, they actually considered it important to learn something they didn’t like,” stated Sandra Staklis, lead author of the RTI report. “One trainee told us, ‘Oh, my mother and my aunt are nurses. Therefore I attempted it out. And it ended up it wasn’t for me, however it was good to understand that.'”
Related: Double registration has exploded. But it’s difficult to tell if it’s helping more kids get a college degree
Trainees also discussed gaining a more comprehensive set of abilities that work in any field. “Students stated they were finding out those work environment skills like time management and dealing with other people on a project,” stated Staklis. “A great deal of academic work traditionally has been more individual, like reading a book or taking a test.”
Still, the findings raise an essential question: Are paths indicated to steer students into specific profession fields, or assist them find out what they do not wish to do?
Trainees likewise described just how much they valued the mentoring they got from their instructors, much of whom didn’t invest their professional lives in schools however in market. One student profiled in the report, Kwame, stated his instructors in the health care field revealed him how to break down dense medical product and so he could study to make his paramedic certification. He’s now learning public health at a four-year college and wishes to end up being a surgeon.
Two lessons stuck out from the Delaware research study.
– Office experience matters most but is hardest for schools to deliver. Students who took part in internships or apprenticeships were most likely to continue in their field, the report found. Another trainee called James, likewise profiled in the report, pursued an education pathway in high school and, during his senior year, he watched an instructor, which taught him a lot about handling class behavior. He’s now pursuing an associate degree in elementary education.
But these chances are tough for schools to provide, needing coordination with companies in addition to solutions for scheduling and transport.
Office learning was more common in trade high schools, where trainees typically total core coursework earlier and can spend more time outside the structure during their senior year. By contrast, one-time experiences– such as guest speakers or school outing– had less effect however were much easier for schools to organize.
– Trainees need much better guidance specifically when they wish to alter instructions. As soon as students start a path, it can be tough to switch. “If you’re a junior and you wish to change to a different path, you ‘d need to go back taking classes that are mainly freshmen and sophomores, and it simply becomes logistically hard to enable that,” said Staklis.
Luke Rhine, vice president for postsecondary success at Rodel, which commissioned the analysis, said the findings were motivating but point to a need for more powerful recommending, which he calls “navigational assistance.”
The report likewise indicates more concerns for future research.
It’s unclear how much of the greater college-going rate can be credited to pathways themselves. The research study is not causal, Staklis said, and trainees who complete these series might already have actually been most likely to pursue additional education. Other rewards to pursue college could likewise be contributing, including Delaware’s generous scholarship programs, which cover tuition at Delaware Technical Neighborhood College and Delaware State University for numerous students.
While a bulk of students were working, most remained in part-time tasks in retail, delivery or fast-food that harmonize their research studies. Longer-term results– including professions and revenues– remain unknown.
Related: Young, utilized– and unhappy
Some researchers question the structure of the paths design in a quickly altering economy. Kerry McKittrick, co-director of the Job on Workforce at Harvard University, issued a report recently, “Pivots Without Pathways: Profession Navigation in a Fragmented Labor Market,” based on an analysis of community university student and young people. McKittrick argues that it might not make sense to need young trainees to go through a sequence of technical training classes for jobs that might not exist in 5 years.
“Paths are an effective alternative, however this linear path to a career is really the exception,” stated McKittrick.”In a world where jobs continue to change, we also require to equip trainees and workers with the abilities they require. … I’m discussing flexibility and choice making and info literacy and networking.”
Those skills, argues McKittrick, aren’t discovered in a class, but through experimentation. What’s most important, according to McKittrick, is for young people to have the opportunity to check out occupations beyond what grownups in their family do and to develop networks.
Significantly, she agrees with one of the Delaware report’s central findings: Workplace experience might be the most valuable element of a paths program.
Contact staffwriter Jill Barshay at 212-678-3595, jillbarshay.35 on Signal, or [email protected].
This story about high school paths was produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent wire service that covers education. Register for Evidence Pointsand other Hechinger newsletters.
Was this story valuable? Leave a suggestion to support your education reporters.
The Hechinger Report is a not-for-profit newsroom powered by reader support
Republish our posts free of charge, online or in print, under an Imaginative Commons license.